Pizza Reviews: Grades for 19 Northern Colorado Pizzerias

I've been traveling around Northern Colorado in search of 'NoCo's Greatest Pie.'

Each week, I take on another area pizzeria and rate it based on its Google review ratings. Establishments can earn up to 5 pepperonis based on my rating scale.

Just how many pepperonis have I awarded to your favorite pizza joint? Check for yourself below.

More Pizza My Heart reviews resume in the new year.

Fort Collins

• Cosmos Pizza, 3.5
• Cozzola's Pizzeria, 3.9
• JJ's Woodfired Pizza, 4.5
• Mama Roni's, 3.7
• Otto Pint, 4.6
• Panhandler's Pizza, 4.1
• Pizza Casbah, 4.6
• Pulcinella Pizzeria, 4.2

Greeley

• Empire State Pizza, 4.1
• Fonta's Pizza: 4.3
• Right Coast Pizza, 4.6
• Santeramo's Pizza House, 4.0

Johnstown

• Mod Pizza: 4.5
• Parry's Pizzeria & Bar, 4.2

Loveland

• Blocky's Eatery, 3.9
• Justine's Pizza, 4.0
• Pizza Steet, 4.0

Windsor

• Anthony's Pizza & Pasta, 4.0
• Pelican Jo's, 3.9